Skip to content
03 545 0877  

The $187,000 Investigation Mistake

The Employment Court has ruled that Optimal Fire Ltd’s investigation into a director and his wife, both company employees, was so one-sided that their suspensions and dismissals were unjustified. The couple were awarded more than $187,000, and the company’s $280,000 counterclaim against them was dismissed.

In the Employment Court case of Gouws v Optimal Fire Ltd (September 2026), Mr Gouws was a founding shareholder, a director and the Assistant Commercial Manager. His wife worked in the company’s HR team.

Trouble began in early 2024, when Mr Gouws bought bicycles for staff under a work ride scheme the directors had discussed but allegedly never formally approved. Questions about the bicycles grew into a broad review of how company money had been spent since 2019, including payments between the four founding directors, their spouses and their private companies.

In late April 2024 the couple were suspended on full pay, without consultation, with only “various transactions” cited. Five days later they received a spreadsheet of years of transactions with little explanation of the alleged wrongdoing. At the investigation meeting on 7 May the allegations had been narrowed to 24 transactions, some simply marked “CLARIFY”. The couple replied on 20 May that the payments were authorised or drawn against money the company owed Mr Gouws. The company rejected their answers two days later and set a next-day deadline for more feedback. On 31 May, five weeks after the suspensions, both were summarily dismissed for misappropriating company funds.

The difficulty for the employer was that its finances had been run very informally. The other directors also had personal expenses paid by the company, including overseas holiday costs, immigration legal fees and dental bills, and none was questioned in the same way.

The couple repeatedly asked for information they said they needed to explain the transactions: accounting records, WhatsApp messages between the directors, shared-drive documents and details of other directors’ spending. The company refused most of these requests, saying the WhatsApp messages were outside its control and that the other directors’ spending was irrelevant because they were not under investigation.

The Court called the resulting investigation “lopsided”. Instead of properly testing the couple’s explanations, the company shut down access to information that might have supported them. It also found no urgency justified suspending them without first hearing from them, and no evidence that either had tried to delete records. Mrs Gouws was treated as a “byproduct” of concerns really aimed at her husband. The evidence fell short of showing that Mr Gouws had mishandled money, and “even further short” for Mrs Gouws.

The remedies were substantial. Mr Gouws received $55,000 compensation for humiliation, loss of dignity and injury to feelings, plus lost wages ($23,076.90) and other contractual payments still to be calculated. Mrs Gouws received $50,000 compensation and $59,575.02 in lost wages, the Court accepting that the allegations and dismissal caused severe harm, including panic attacks needing medical treatment. Reinstatement was declined because the relationship had broken down beyond repair. The company was also ordered to repay holiday pay unlawfully deducted from their final pay.

Most striking was the $280,000 counterclaim, which the Court dismissed. The company’s figure had shrunk repeatedly, from an early estimate above $868,000 to $384,124 and then $285,740, before falling to $280,056 after its own expert admitted double-counting an item. The Court instead found Mr Gouws had built up a credit balance of about $339,000 through deferred salary, initial capital contributions and unpaid loans.

The lesson for employers is clear: if you suspect fraud, theft or dishonesty, investigate it, but do not let the seriousness of the allegation decide the outcome before the investigation is finished.

Tell the employee precisely what they are suspected of doing, share the information behind the allegations, give them reasonable access to what they need to respond, and genuinely consider their explanations. Equally, look for evidence that could disprove your suspicions, not just evidence that supports them.

A good disciplinary investigation is not about building a case for dismissal. It is about establishing, as fairly and objectively as possible, what actually happened. Gouws v Optimal Fire Ltd is a dramatic reminder of how costly it can be when an employer forgets that.

You get reassurance that your employment matters are dealt with professionally, so you can go back to doing what you do best.

Help with anything in the employment life cycle from recruitment and employment agreements to disciplinaries and disputes and anything else in between.

Contact

Follow Us

Location

Physical Address:
Commerce House – Level 1, 54 Montgomery Square, Nelson, 7010

Postal Address:
PO Box 1615 Nelson, 7040

Our Newsfeed

Subscribe to our News Feed for the latest industry updates.

Subscribe to our News Feed
Back To Top
Your Cart

Your cart is empty.